When penetration testing is conducted by an external security team, it’s called external penetration testing. External penetration testing can be very detailed encompassing source code review, manual inspection, etc. Or may also just focus on the publicly accessible assets of an organization’s system & network, as per the requirements.
Commonly, penetration testing is performed for web apps, mobile apps, network & network devices, and so on.
In the above context, there is another kind of penetration testing – Internal penetration testing. Internal penetration testing, as you’d have guessed, is conducted by an in-house security team in an organization.
Note: Penetration testing of external systems – those accessible via the Internet – is also sometimes called external penetration testing. External systems usually include – web apps, networks, routers, switches, sub-domains, login systems, etc. This type of penetration testing is popularly known as Network penetration testing.
Difference between internal & external penetration testing?
Internal and external penetration testing have their own benefits and limitations. You’ll understand them better by looking at their differences:
|Type||Internal Penetration Testing||External Penetration Testing|
|1.||Internal penetration testing is done by in-house security researchers.||External penetration testing is done by an independent team of security researchers.|
|2.||It can be costly to maintain a full-time security team.||It is cost-effective to outsource security testing.|
|3.||Since in-house security researchers know the ins & outs of a system, they often struggle to look at it from a hacker’s perspective.||External penetration testing offers a fresh perspective on the system’s security and is great at emulating a hacker’s behavior on the target system.|
|4.||Internal penetration testing requires less planning and can be done more frequently.||Since it’s an outside engagement, it is time taking to conduct frequently. Check out this blog to get an idea of how much penetration testing costs.|
|5.||Internal penetration testing does not suffice in compliance requirements.||External penetration testing is necessary to comply with various compliances.|
Difference between external penetration testing & vulnerability scanning?
When talking about penetration testing, another word that often comes up is ‘Vulnerability Scanning‘. Vulnerability Scanning (aka automated penetration testing) is the process of scanning your application with the help of security tools. It is primarily an automated process, barring the manual verification at the end of the scan.
Vulnerability scanning is quick to perform and is cost-effective. Here are some other differences between external penetration testing and vulnerability scanning:
|Type||External Penetration Testing||Vulnerability Scanning|
|1.||Penetration testing is an evaluation of your current security status through a series of systematic manual & automated tests.||Vulnerability Scanning is out and out an automated process that detects all possible exploitable surfaces in a system.|
|2.||Penetration testing is a thorough process of identifying vulnerabilities and determining their impact. It involves the exploitation of vulnerabilities to see the complete picture.||Vulnerability Scanning deals with just the basic inventory of vulnerabilities and does not involve exploitation to gauge impact.|
|3.||Penetration testing is a complex and intricate process. One needs to have the proper education & experience to conduct it successfully.||Vulnerability Scanning is easy and pretty straightforward to conduct. One can conduct vulnerability scanning with a basic idea of the right tools and steps.|
|4.||Conducting penetration testing, that too external penetration testing is a time-taking affair, and can take several days to several weeks to complete. It’s harder to replicate the entire process every week, or on-demand so to say.||Vulnerability Scanning takes a few seconds to a couple of minutes to complete. So, you can conduct vulnerability scanning regularly, without much planning & pain.|
|5.||Since penetration testing involves long hours of manual effort and is high on human intelligence, it invariably costs more.||Vulnerability Scanning is cost-effective.|
|6.||The reporting in external penetration tests provides a detailed explanation of the vulnerabilities found, including proofs-of-concept, CVSS score, bug bounty loss, steps to reproduce & steps to fix.||Vulnerability Scanning reports usually just list the vulnerabilities in order of severity, without going too deep into explaining each vulnerability.|
Here’s an example of a Vulnerability Scan report by Astra’s Pentest Scanner:
5 Steps involved in an external penetration testing
Planning avoids chaos. To conduct a successful & systematic external penetration test you need to follow a process. Broadly speaking, external penetration testing can be broken down into five steps:
This is the phase where the tester & the client decide on the terms of the engagement, pentesting methodology, types of tests, security objectives, & outcomes to avoid any mismatches.
To make the most of an external pentest, you (the client) must have answers to these questions ready:
- Why do I need pentesting
- What am I trying to achieve from it
- Will I need additional tests
- What approach I am looking at? Black-box, white-box, gray-box
- What assets are crucial to my organization and should be prioritized
- Do I have certification requirements, and so on.
Once you’ve everything working for you, you can flag off the penetration testing after closing the deal and signing an NDA (Non-disclosure agreements).
2. Scope defining or Reconnaissance
Scope defining is where you recognize your assets (web pages, user roles, APIs, networks, etc.) that would undergo the pentest. This is also the part where both the parties share necessary details & access.
It is generally during this step, security researchers & the organization decide on the type of penetration test to conduct.
For instance, if your organization needs its network to be tested, you may need network penetration testing, if you need to test your web app, you need web app pentesting, and so on. But since most organizations have a little more complex structure, you may likely need a combination of these tests to fulfill your security objectives.
Exploitation is the most exciting and important part of penetration testing. This is where pentesters try to penetrate your system with a series of attacks.
For example, our automated vulnerability scanner scans an application or network for 2500+ vulnerabilities. Some of them are shown in this picture:
Other than Astra’s pentest scanner, here are some tools (in no particular order) that come in handy during this process:
NOTE: The tests in this step vary from application to application. You may need to add/remove certain tools to cater to the unique requirements of an organization.
If you’re conducting penetration testing yourself, make sure you have all the necessary accesses, documented scope, and the right tools with you. Refer to these blog posts for detailed steps involved in manual penetration testing:
- How to Conduct A Web Application Penetration Testing?
- What is Network Penetration Testing & How to Perform It?
- A Complete Guide on Cloud Penetration Testing
4. Reporting & Remediation
After the test, the tester documents the findings in a detailed yet crisp report. An ideal penetration testing report should contain details of the vulnerabilities, CVSS score, steps to reproduce, steps to fix, etc. A penetration testing report should also sum up the core insight of the report in a short & comprehensible summary that can be reviewed at a glance.
Here’s a sample report by Astra Security for your reference.
Coming to Remediation. This is where the organization needs to fix the reported vulnerabilities. Fixing the vulnerabilities well within the engagement’s validity will mean the tester will retest the deployed fixes. Failure to meet the deadline would require a new engagement or additional costs for the rescan.
Most pentesting reports provide fixing help, some pentesting companies like Astra Security even offer direct assistance to developers in fixing the vulnerabilities. Deploy those fixes and implement best security practices as suggested.
For example, at Astra, we share detailed steps to fix as well as a platform to ask doubts in our dashboard.
5. Re-Scan & Certification
External penetration testing ends with the penetration tester testing the fixes and best practices implemented by you. If the vulnerabilities are patched effectively, the security team/company will issue a pentest certificate to your organization.
Get an external pentest with Astra Security now
If you’re looking for in-depth, hassle-free external penetration testing, you’ve found one with Astra Security 🙂
Astra Security offers a thorough external penetration testing service with over 2500+ tests – Manual & Automated. Astra Pentest provides an intuitive pentest dashboard that facilitates real-time vulnerability reporting, management & collaboration for each vulnerability, thus cutting the vulnerability fixing time for developers.
Here are a few features of the Astra Pentest:
- Hacker-style penetration testing (with over 2500+ tests)
- Developer-friendly intuitive dashboard
- Real-time vulnerability reporting (first set of vulnerabilities added within 24 hours)
- Direct collaboration (no email threads)
- Vulnerability PoCs & selenium scripts
- Fixing advice
- Detailed reports
- Publicly verifiable certificates.
Also check out the new features added to our pentest dashboard.