In 2023 alone, the payments industry handled north of 3.4 trillion transactions worth >$1.8 quadrillion. Conversely, card payment fraud exceeded $32 billion, while online payment fraud is expected to drain $360 billion worldwide between 2023 and 2028. 

It is against this backdrop that the PCI DSS Level 1 stands as the highest standard for card payment security, intended for firms that process over 6 million Visa or Mastercard transactions annually. It unlocks customer trust at a global scale, lowers breach-related costs (nearly $5M per data breach on average), reduces insurance premiums, and makes partnerships with major financial institutions far easier to land.

Whether you’re building Level 1 compliance from scratch or enhancing what’s already in place, this guide is for teams securing payments and anyone curious about how the system remains up and running around the clock.

Why Astra is the best in Third-Party Pentesting?

• We’re the only company that combines automated & manual pentest to create a one-of-a-kind PTaaS platform with SOC 2 vulnerability tags.
• Vetted scans ensure zero false positives. to avoid delays.
• Our intelligent vulnerability scanner emulates hacker behavior with 10,000+ tests to help achieve continuous compliance
• Astra’s scanner helps you simplify remediation by integrating with your CI/CD
• Our platform helps you uncover, manage & fix vulnerabilities in one place
• We offer 2 rescans to help you verify ptaches and generate a clean report
• Trusted by the brands you trust like Agora, Spicejet, Muthoot, Dream11, etc.

Let’s Talk Get Started

What are the Technical Security Requirements?

Building a Future-Proof Network Security Architecture

The core network security architecture forms the backbone of your payments enterprise, and therefore, it cannot be limited to next-gen firewalls alone. PCI DSS Level 1 compliance demands sophistication that moves beyond preliminary, peripheral defense strategies.

The need is to efficiently isolate CDEs (Cardholder Data Environments) from the wider network infrastructure via multi-layered security controls. This entails complementing your next-gen firewalls with:

• Deep packet inspection capabilities
• Intrusion Detection & Prevention Systems
• Advanced threat correlation engines
• Granular access policies via NAC (Network Access Control) solutions
• Continuous manual and AI-infused hacker-style pentests simulating real-world threat scenarios and external vulnerability assessments via ASVs (Approved Scanning Vendors).

Additionally, the network topology documentation mandate requires comprehensive architectural diagrams, including data flow mappings, security control implementations, and network connection inventories. This is to precisely and accurately reflect all system components within the CDE.

Implementing Military-Grade Data Protection Protocols

PCI DSS Level 1 compliance mandates enterprise-grade cryptographic implementations for data in transit, at rest, and during active processing operations. This includes:

• AES-256 symmetric encryption for cardholder data
• TLS 1.2 or higher for all data transmission channels 
• Implementing distributed key storage mechanisms, automated rotation procedures, and resilient key generation algorithms.
• Detailed audit trails for key lifecycle operations. 

The database security architecture also needs to incorporate field-level encryption for sensitive card payment data elements through methods such as masking, truncation, complex hashing, and encryption. 

This needs to be backed up by DLP (Data Loss Prevention) solutions that monitor and control the movement of cardholder data across network boundaries, capable of detecting and acting upon unauthorized data exfiltration attempts through defined incident response procedures. 

Enabling Zero-Trust Access Control across the Authentication Architecture

Level 1 mandates within the access control frameworks require:

• Complex IAM solutions across all system components adhering to zero-trust principles
• MFA from administrative access to CDE elements. 
• Incorporating PAM (Privileged Access Management) solutions that offer granular control and thorough monitoring of admin activities. 
• RBAC to include automated access provisioning and de-provisioning workflows, periodic access certification drives, etc.
• Establishing formal Identity lifecycle management procedures that monitor revocations, access grants, and modifications, with special emphasis on emergency access procedures that ensure security without interrupting business continuity. 

Enforcing Layered Physical Security Defence Mechanisms

Physical security in today’s fast-paced, big data, and interconnected era requires comprehensive facility security programs with multi-layer verifications. This involves implementing:

• Biometric access control systems
• Video surveillance networks with motion detection and facial recognition capabilities
• Media handling procedures that cover the complete physical storage lifecycle of devices that include cardholder data, storage encryption protocols, certified transportation, chain-of-custody documentation, and data destruction services that ensure media sanitization. 

The Journey from Preparation to Certification 

Pre-Assessment Phase (3-6 months approx.)

This critical phase, which can last up to 6 months, involves the development of an elaborate security architecture. Here, you essentially begin with an extensive gap analysis, where your current security posture is compared against the technical requirements a PCI DSS Level 1 service provider should have. 

This phase requires independent validation of your compliance readiness through multiple preliminary technical assessments and security architecture reviews. 

Partnerships, thus, with a PCI-DSS ASV that possesses scalable and cutting-edge continuous penetration testing, vulnerability assessment, and reporting capabilities, provided by certified professionals, become crucial for developing the best security monitoring frameworks that encompass your entire compliance lifecycle.

This partnership also follows through with your documentation preparation phase, which involves:

• Policy development
• Technical procedures documentation
• Network architecture blueprints
• System inventory catalogues 
• Evidence collection frameworks. 

QSA Selection and Engagement

Selecting a Qualified Security Assessor is a strategic decision that’ll impact both current assessment outcomes and your future compliance success. An ideal QSA ensures a thorough understanding of not only PCI DSS Level 1’s technical mandates but also the specific operational woes within your industry vertical.

Thus, evaluate your QSA based on the depth of technical expertise, industry-specific experience, geographic accessibility, certifications, and experiences held by its professionals, as well as its analysis and reporting dexterity, and its cultural alignment with your existing firm-wide structures. 

Technical Assessment (1-2 months approx.)

This action-critical phase involves comprehensive security checks, including rigorous and offensive penetration testing engagements, network-wide vulnerability assessments (API cloud, mobile, and web-app), process validations across CDE components, and thorough configuration audits. 

During this phase, your firm must maintain dedicated technical teams to ensure a smooth and rapid response to your QSA’s technical requests and the immediate resolution of highlighted vulnerabilities and security gaps. 

Post-Assessment Activities

Post-assessment activities include addressing identified vulnerabilities and security gaps, procuring final documentation, and implementing continuous compliance monitoring programs.

To assist you in this regard, the final ROC (Report on Compliance) is a comprehensive document that serves as the primary reference for current and planned security monitoring activities. 

Following compliance, you should conduct quarterly vulnerability scans, continuous penetration test evaluations, security awareness training sessions, policy reviews, and incident response procedures in the event of a payment card security breach.

No other pentest product combines automated scanning + expert guidance like we do.

Discuss your security
needs & get started today!

Schedule your call

What are Some Common Mistakes & Challenges?

Technical Implementation Hurdles

These hurdles primarily arise when you underestimate the multidimensional complexity of securing enterprise-grade, distributed payment processing environments. Following this, you may encounter issues while isolating legacy payment systems that lack modern-day security architecture foundations. 

Additionally, deploying encryption across databases will also be challenging, as you attempt to balance application performance with securing cardholder data at the field level. Such implementations thus require a shift-left approach and careful balancing between operational efficiency, security requirements, and disaster recovery capabilities. 

Integrating a diverse array of security tools with your technology stack is also not a smooth ride, especially when it comes to implementing continuous pentesting, vulnerability assessment, and SIEM solutions. 

Organisational and Process-Related Roadblocks

Established operational procedures, complex reporting hierarchies, and change management resistance, particularly in large-scale enterprises, make the road to fundamental modifications, especially those that impact customer-facing and mission-critical functions, tougher. 

Additionally, there are resource allocation challenges, communication gaps among technical security teams, and complex reporting issues that can become significant hurdles, especially when companies lack clear governance structures and decision-making processes related to their security and technology domains. 

Regulatory and Industry-Specific Concerns

Balancing PCI DSS compliance requirements with other industry-specific regulatory frameworks, such as GDPR, SOX, and HIPAA, requires a significant investment of human and financial capital.

Conflicts among security objectives, geographic considerations (for MNCs), judicial prudence, data residency mandates, cross-border data transfer restrictions, and local privacy regulations can have a disturbing impact on security architectures and operational procedures. 

Additionally, managing multiple third-party vendors that handle various payment processing operations increases the complexity for PCI DSS service provider Level 1 certifications.

How can Astra Security Help?

Key Features:

• Platform: SaaS-based VAPT with continuous compliance tracking
• Testing: Automated scans + manual pentests by OSCP, CEH, eWPTXv2, etc. experts
• Certifications: PCI-ASV, CREST-certified, CERT-IN empaneled
• Coverage: Web and mobile apps, API, IAM, cloud infrastructure, and networks/ workspaces
• Reporting: Audience-tailored QSA-ready reports with mapped controls and fix validation
• Integrations: Works with JIRA, Slack, GitHub, GitLab, Jenkins, and other CI/CD platforms

Astra combines deep manual testing with 15,000+ automated scans (new ones added every fortnight) tailored to the PCI data standard’s technical requirements. From insecure authentication and weak access controls to misconfigured cloud infrastructure, it identifies vulnerabilities that could put cardholder data at risk before auditors or attackers do.

As a PCI DSS Level 1 compliant security provider, all findings are validated by certified security professionals and delivered with mapped PCI control references, severity scores, and clear remediation steps. This not only speeds up resolution but also ensures your internal teams and QSA auditors have precisely what they need. No back-and-forth, no guesswork.

With continuous monitoring, real-time dashboards, and seamless integrations into your existing workflows, Astra helps service providers maintain a strong security posture year-round.

Astra Security vs Leading PCI DSS Security Service Providers

Astra Security’s Strategic Advantages:

• Provides end-to-end PCI pentesting services for continuous threat monitoring across assets. 
• Possesses fintech-focused deep pentesting and vulnerability assessment capabilities. 
• Holds both ASV certification and in-house technical and administrative QSA expertise.
• AI-powered tests for improved manual pentesting and zero false positives (with vetted scans)
• Seamless integrations with Slack, Jira, GitHub, GitLab, and Jenkins
• CXO-friendly dashboard with a dedicated CSM
• Unlimited automated scans for existing and emerging CVEs 
• Dedicated communication channels on Slack/ Teams

Astra Pentest is built by the team of experts that helped secure Microsoft, Adobe, Facebook, and Buffer

Book a Demo View Pricing

Who are Key Level 1 PCI DSS Service Providers in Cloud?

These firms excel at delivering pre-configured, certified environments by maintaining their own Level 1 certifications. They offer shared responsibility models that reduce the compliance burden on customers.

Amazon Web Services (AWS)

Pros:

• Comprehensive portfolio of PCI DSS Level 1 compliant services such as EC2, RDS, S3, and Lambda. 
• Segment leading security infrastructure via AWS Config, CloudTrail, GuardDuty & Security Hub. 
• Global presence and security consulting partner ecosystem across multiple industries. 

Limitations:

• A complex shared responsibility model that adds a burden on the security analysis. 
• The learning curve is quite significant, especially for firms new to cloud security architecture, which requires the development of in-house technical expertise.
• Cost escalations occur with every new implementation of advanced security features.

Microsoft Azure

Pros:

• Tried and tested robust hybrid cloud expertise that also supports on-prem integrations
• Seamless integrations with existing Microsoft enterprise technology stacks
• Excellent support and pricing models for Windows-based payment processing apps and other software systems.

Limitations:

• You’re cooked if your technological stacks and security architecture are void of Microsoft enterprise systems.
• The third-party security ecosystem is less extensive as compared to AWS
• Limited Linux support capabilities and additional licensing investments required for advanced security features
• Fewer PCI DSS-compliant security tools as opposed to AWS

Google Cloud Platform (GCP)

Pros:

• Offers cutting-edge fraud detection with emphasis on AI/ML-based data analytics
• Strongly inclined towards open source security technologies
• Industry-best container security and Kubernetes support

Limitations:

• Smaller market share with limited enterprise support capabilities compared to Azure and AWS
• Less extensive PCI DSS implementation-related documentation, along with compliance-specific tools and resources
• New to the business with comparatively less expertise in enterprise-level deployments

Comparative Analysis of Cloud Service Providers

It is one small security loophole v/s your entire website or web application.

Get your web app audited with
Astra’s Continuous Pentest Solution.

Explore Features Schedule a meeting

What are Some Key Payment Processing Platforms?

Final Thoughts

Becoming a Level 1 PCI DSS compliant service provider is a continuous and comprehensive security transformation journey that requires expert and tailored security guidance, strategic partnerships, and planning, as well as a no-compromise commitment to security excellence. 

The approach here requires implementing sophisticated, yet easy-to-navigate and robust security architectures that provide long-term business value and a competitive advantage in today’s ever-expanding and increasingly sophisticated threat landscape. 

From threat vectors, posture assessments, documentation, reporting, to ongoing penetration testing, vulnerability management, and third-party certification through experienced ASVs and QSAs, the landscape of top-tier PCI DSS service providers, Level 1 (cloud platforms, payment processors, etc.) adds critical context to what excellence in compliance looks like today.

FAQs